Working for someone vs working for yourself
With a job, you get paid the same whether it's a busy day or a quiet one — safe, but capped. With your own thing, a bad week pays nothing and a great week pays a lot. Neither one is better; they're different trades.
- Week 1 — Cara$4
- Week 2 — Cara$11
- Week 3 — Cara$6
- Week 4 — Cara$0
Nothing at all that week
- Week 5 — Cara$71
School fair
- Any week — Nabil$30
Every single Saturday, guaranteed
Cara made $92 over those five weeks; Nabil made $150 and knew every number in advance. Different people should pick differently.
Do this
Draw two columns and list what's good and bad about each. Notice that the good things are opposites.
Say this
"Would you rather have $10 guaranteed, or a coin flip between $0 and $30? There's no right answer — but know which one you picked."
A story
The two paper rounds
Nabil delivered papers for the shop and got $30 every Saturday, rain or shine, busy or quiet. His friend Cara made and sold custom bookmarks. One week Cara made $4. The week before the school fair she made $71. Over the whole term they earned almost exactly the same amount, and neither of them would have swapped.
Which one had the better deal?
Neither. Nabil bought certainty and gave up the good weeks. Cara kept the good weeks and gave up knowing what Saturday would bring. That is a trade, not a ranking.
The usual mistake
Teaching that working for yourself is obviously better. It is not obviously anything — it is a different risk, and plenty of people should not take it.
The fix
Make them name what each side gives up. The good things about a job and a business are exact opposites of each other.
