Today is rung 5 of 13 on this topic
The argument essay
Can do: Writes a thesis, supports it with evidence, addresses a counter-argument, and concludes.
Why it matters
This is the dominant form of assessed writing for the next decade. The counter-argument is what separates a persuasive essay from a rant.
What it looks like when it's wobbly
Presents only their own side, or mentions the other side without ever answering it.
⏱️ Two-minute check
"What's the strongest argument against your position, and what's your answer to it?"
Solid looks like: A real opposing argument, fairly stated, then answered.
The full activity for this topic · 25 minutes
Steelman First
- 1Before writing their own side, they write the strongest possible version of the opposite view.
- 2Then write their thesis and two supporting paragraphs with evidence.
- 3Add a paragraph that quotes the opposing view and answers it directly.
- 4Check the conclusion says something new rather than repeating the introduction.
- 5Read it to someone who disagrees and see whether it holds.
If it's too hard
Thesis plus two reasons; add the counter-argument next time.
If it's too easy
Argue the side they don't hold, convincingly.
Say this
"Make the other side sound smart first. If you can't, you don't understand it yet."